Skip to game
Ballpark Sim
Games

Legends1901–2025 peaks

MLB All-Time Matchup Simulator

Play the MLB all-time matchup simulator with thirty historical franchise squads. Set the lineup, choose an ace and compare era-adjusted peak seasons.

Loading rosters…
This is taking longer than usual.Get helpAll games
Loading rosters…

An all-time baseball simulator across eras

Use the historical baseball simulator to put franchise greats from different eras on the same field. These curated all-time squads use selected peak seasons from 1901–2025, with ratings adjusted for each player’s league environment.

An all-time squad combines different peak seasons

These are curated franchise selections from 1901–2025, not recreations of a single historical club. Each player represents a selected peak season with that franchise. The same person can therefore appear as a separate version on more than one club.

Check the selected players before making the lineup. An all-time matchup asks what those versions might do together inside this model; it does not mean that the group ever shared a clubhouse or played the box score shown here.

Why the ratings adjust for the player’s own league

A batting line from one era comes from a different scoring environment than a line from another. The game compares selected peak-season rates with the player’s own league environment before converting them into modern game ratings. That gives the matchup a common framework.

It cannot settle every difference in rules, equipment or competition. Use the box score to explore the matchup, then read the historical-rating method if you want to understand the assumptions behind the result.

Play one argument, or take a club on tour

A standalone matchup or best-of series is the quick way to compare two squads. A Legends Tour keeps one club across five stops. Choose a route, set the nine and starter, manage key innings and collect franchise stamps from the recorded series.

Pitcher use follows the club through supported tours, so planning the next start matters. A shared tour can be reviewed separately before you keep it. To play with the modern community roster snapshots instead, return to the MLB game simulator.

About this game: rules, data and questions

Playing and keeping this game

How to play

  1. Pick the baseball argument

    Choose two franchise squads for a standalone matchup, or select a club and a five-stop tour route.

  2. Choose a historical version

    Check the peak-season players, lineup and available starters. The ratings adjust each selected season for its league environment.

  3. Play for the passport

    Complete tour series, collect franchise stamps and replay the stops you lost. A standalone game or series remains available for a shorter visit.

Are these official MLB all-time teams?

No. They are independent, curated statistical fantasy squads, selected from historical seasons and adjusted for the game.

Can one player appear on two franchises?

Yes. A qualifying peak season with one club is a separate historical version from a peak season with another.

What does era-adjusted mean here?

Selected statistics are compared with the player’s own league environment before being converted to modern internal ratings. The method does not remove every difference between eras.

Can I play a series rather than one game?

Yes. Standalone play supports a game or series. The saved five-stop tour provides a longer route with its own progression.

Can I edit the lineup and choose the starter?

Yes. Set the batting order and an available starter before playing. Tour choices and recorded game progress are retained with that run.

More games

All games